How We Choose Filters

How We Choose Filters: illustration of a water quality guide

Every recommendation on TapWaterWise follows the same process. Here is what we look at, in order, and what we refuse to do.

1. Start with the water

A filter is only worth buying if it fixes a problem you actually have. So we start with your water source:

  • City water: your utility’s annual water quality report (the Consumer Confidence Report) lists what was detected and at what levels. Our city pages summarize it and link to it.
  • Private well: wells are not covered by those reports, so we recommend a lab test before buying any treatment system.

2. Match the contaminant to a certification

We only say a filter reduces a contaminant when there is evidence we can link to. In order of preference:

  1. Certification by an accredited body (such as NSF, IAPMO or WQA) to an NSF/ANSI standard that covers that contaminant
  2. Published third-party lab results from an independent lab, with the report available
  3. Manufacturer claims only: we label these clearly as unverified

The standards that matter most:

Standard What it covers
NSF/ANSI 42 Aesthetic issues such as chlorine, taste and odor
NSF/ANSI 53 Contaminants with health effects, such as lead
NSF/ANSI 58 Reverse osmosis systems
NSF/ANSI 401 Certain emerging contaminants, such as some pharmaceuticals
NSF/ANSI 44 Water softeners (hardness)
NSF/ANSI 55 Ultraviolet (UV) systems for microorganisms
NSF/ANSI 177 Shower filters (free chlorine)

A certification covers specific contaminants, not everything. A filter certified to NSF/ANSI 53 for lead is not automatically certified for anything else, so we check the listing, not just the standard number.

3. Count the real cost

The price tag is only part of it. We compare:

  • Replacement filters: how often, and what they cost per year
  • Installation: plug-and-play, a plumber, or a do-it-yourself job
  • Water waste: reverse osmosis systems send some water down the drain
  • Warranty and return window

4. Check the fit for your home

  • Flow rate for whole-house systems, so showers do not lose pressure
  • Size and space under the sink, on the counter or at the main line
  • Water type: chloramine, iron, sulfur, sediment and hardness each need different media

What we never do

  • Accept payment for a review or a higher ranking
  • Claim hands-on testing we did not do
  • Make health claims a certification does not support
  • Recommend a filter when your water report shows no problem it would fix

Affiliate links

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It does not change our picks. See our Affiliate Disclosure.

Sources: NSF: Standards for water treatment systems · EPA: Understanding your water quality report