Epic Pure vs Brita vs Clearly Filtered Pitchers

Disclosure: we may earn a commission from links on this page, at no cost to you. How we choose filters.

Epic Pure vs Brita vs Clearly Filtered Pitchers: illustration comparing two water filters

Short answer: If you want a pitcher whose lead reduction is formally certified, the Brita Elite filter is the only one of the three with an NSF/ANSI 53 lead certification. Epic Pure and Clearly Filtered advertise much broader reduction, including PFAS and fluoride, but those claims rest on lab testing the companies commissioned, while their actual certifications cover only chlorine taste and odor (NSF/ANSI 42) and lead-free materials (NSF/ANSI/CAN 372).

That distinction drives the whole comparison. Below we line up Epic Pure vs Brita vs Clearly Filtered on certifications, filter life, yearly cost and who each pitcher suits. We built it from each maker’s official product pages and certification statements; we did not test the pitchers ourselves.

Key takeaways

  • Certified lead reduction: Brita Elite only (NSF/ANSI 53, listed by IAPMO R&T, NSF and WQA). The cheaper Brita Standard filter is not certified for lead.
  • PFAS and fluoride: Epic Pure and Clearly Filtered both claim high reduction based on third-party lab tests, not certification. Brita makes no PFOA/PFOS claim.
  • Cheapest to run: Brita Elite, at 120 gallons per filter. Clearly Filtered costs the most per year.
  • Best fit: Brita Elite for certified lead protection on a budget; Epic Pure or Clearly Filtered if you value broad claimed reduction and accept that it isn’t certified.

Water filter pitchers compared: quick facts

Epic Pure (Pure XP)Brita Tahoe with Elite filterClearly Filtered pitcher
Approx. priceAbout $79–$82About $42About $93.50–$110
Filter life100 gallons (XP cartridge)120 gallons, about 6 months100 gallons, about 3 months for an average family
Replacement filter6-pack works out to about $0.46/galAbout $19.99 listingAbout $58.50–$65 each
Estimated yearly filter costAbout $140–$185About $40 (2 filters)About $234–$260 (4 filters)
CertificationsNSF/ANSI 42, NSF/ANSI/CAN 372NSF/ANSI 42, 53, 401NSF/ANSI 42, 372
Certified for lead?No (tested, not certified)Yes, NSF/ANSI 53No (tested, not certified)
PFAS claimYes, lab testedNone madeYes, lab tested
CapacityNot stated on product page10 cups80 oz (10 cups)
Warranty3 yearsNot stated on product pageLimited lifetime

Prices are approximate and change often; yearly costs are our estimates from each brand’s rated filter life and listed filter prices.

Certifications: the part most reviews skip

A pitcher can be “tested to” a standard or “certified to” it. Certification means an accredited body such as NSF, IAPMO R&T or WQA verified the claim, lists the product publicly and audits the factory. “Tested to” means the company paid a lab to run the protocol once. Testing isn’t worthless, but it isn’t the same promise, and it’s the main way these three pitchers differ.

Brita Elite

Brita’s Elite performance data page lists certification to NSF/ANSI 42, 53 and 401 by IAPMO R&T, NSF International and WQA. Under Standard 53 it reports about 99.5% lead reduction, plus mercury, cadmium, asbestos and several pesticides and solvents. Standard 401 covers emerging compounds such as BPA, ibuprofen and microplastics. NSF lists the lead claim specifically for the Pacifica and Tidal pitchers, and IAPMO lists it for a wider set of Brita pitcher models, so check that your pitcher model is on the sheet. The page makes no PFOA or PFOS claim.

Don’t confuse it with the Brita Standard filter, which WQA certifies to Standards 42 and 53 for chlorine, zinc, copper, cadmium and mercury, but not lead.

Epic Pure

Epic’s own NSF page shows the Pure filter certified to NSF/ANSI 42 for chlorine and to NSF/ANSI/CAN 372 for lead-free materials. Its broader claims, including lead, PFOA, PFOS and fluoride, come from third-party testing to Standards 53 and 401 and NSF P231. Epic’s help center says plainly that the Pure filter hasn’t been certified by NSF for those claims. Epic’s 2023 data sheet reports 99.94% lead and over 99.6% PFOA reduction in that testing. Our full Epic Pure pitcher review goes deeper.

Clearly Filtered

Clearly Filtered’s certification answer names NSF International certification to NSF/ANSI 42 (chlorine) and NSF/ANSI 372 (lead-free materials). Everything else, its “365+” or “386+” contaminant list (the product page uses both figures), comes from independent testing by EPA-accredited labs. The comparison chart claims 99.34% lead, over 99.5% PFOS and over 99.54% fluoride reduction. Those are notable numbers, but they are the company’s test results rather than a certification you can look up.

Cost of ownership

The upfront price matters less than filters over a few years. Brita’s Elite is rated for 120 gallons, which Brita equates to about six months for an average family, so two filters a year at the $19.99 listed price comes to roughly $40 (Brita’s listing doesn’t state the pack size, so treat that as an estimate). Epic Pure XP cartridges last 100 gallons; Epic advertises its six-pack as low as about $0.46 per gallon, which puts a typical household somewhere around $140 to $185 a year. Clearly Filtered rates its filter at 100 gallons, roughly three months, and its autoship price is about $58.50 (regular $65), or around $234 to $260 a year with four filters.

Over three years, including the pitcher, that’s roughly $160 for Brita, $500 to $640 for Epic Pure and $800 or more for Clearly Filtered. If your household drinks a lot of water, run the numbers with your own gallons.

Who each pitcher is for

Choose Brita Elite if

  • You need certified lead reduction because of a lead or unknown service line, and want the lowest running cost.
  • Your city’s report shows chlorine taste is the main complaint.
  • Not for: households specifically worried about PFAS or wanting fluoride removed.

Choose Epic Pure if

  • You want broad claimed reduction, including PFAS and fluoride, at a mid-range yearly cost, and you accept that those claims are tested rather than certified.
  • Not for: anyone who needs a certification on file for lead (a landlord or daycare setting, say).

Choose Clearly Filtered if

  • You want the longest list of claimed contaminants and a lifetime warranty, and the higher filter cost doesn’t bother you.
  • Not for: budget buyers or anyone who needs certified lead or PFAS reduction.

Pros and cons

PitcherProsCons
Brita EliteCertified lead reduction (NSF/ANSI 53); cheapest filters; 6-month filter life; widely soldNo PFAS or fluoride claim; Standard filter (sold alongside) does not cover lead
Epic PureBroad tested claims including PFAS and fluoride; 3-year warranty; backward-compatible cartridgesHealth claims not certified; filters cost several times Brita’s per year
Clearly FilteredLongest tested contaminant list; limited lifetime warranty; Tritan, BPA- and BPS-free bodyHighest yearly cost; claims not certified; contaminant count differs across its own page

Verdict

For most readers, the deciding question is whether you need certified lead reduction. If yes, the Brita Elite is the clear pick among these three, and it’s also the cheapest to run. If your concern is PFAS, none of the three is certified for it, so a pitcher is a stopgap; a certified under-sink system is the stronger answer (see what filter removes PFAS and our reverse osmosis guide). Between Epic Pure and Clearly Filtered, Epic costs less per year and Clearly Filtered offers the longer warranty. Check your city’s report first: our tap water by city pages show what’s actually in your water.

Browse more pitcher and shower filter picks or see more reviews.

FAQ

Which water filter pitcher is certified to remove lead?

Of these three, only the Brita Elite filter is certified for lead, to NSF/ANSI 53, with listings by IAPMO R&T, NSF and WQA. Epic Pure and Clearly Filtered report lead reduction from lab testing but are certified only to NSF/ANSI 42 and 372.

Does a Brita pitcher remove PFAS?

Brita’s Elite performance data lists no PFOA or PFOS reduction claim. For PFAS, look for a filter certified to NSF/ANSI 53 or 58 for PFOA/PFOS, such as some reverse osmosis systems.

Is Clearly Filtered better than Brita?

It depends on the goal. Clearly Filtered claims to reduce far more contaminants, including PFAS and fluoride, but those claims are tested, not certified, and its filters cost much more per year. Brita Elite has certified lead reduction and lower running costs.

Sources: Brita Elite performance data, Brita Standard performance data, Brita Tahoe pitcher with Elite filter, Brita lead reduction page, Epic Water Filters (Pure XP product, NSF and help-center pages), Clearly Filtered pitcher page and Clearly Filtered certification FAQ.